Clubs with high youth recruitment ratings are often the clubs that get the best youth intakes. It's basically something that I don't understand fully but I have an idea about how it works that needs ore experience/evidence. I know I certainly am. Home Dressing Room - General FM and Football Discussion - II, The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil in Me. Check our Top Heads of Youth Development shortlist! 12. Each year, the FM community spends countless hours improving every part of their youth setup to get the best youth intakes, but it can still be a tricky thing to master. Its pretty easy, actually, but well hidden. after their name is a potential star and I have to put the work in with them. 11. Initially I posted a reply to the video, (and no I'm not going to link to it in here), but I deleted my post and instead of telling you what I know and what I think, I'm going to run some experiments and let the results speak for themselves. Is it better to loan players out for match experience? One is called Game Importance and the other one is Youth Rating. Getting a youth intake in football manager that has the description has the potential to be a real golden generation for the club is really rare and most of the time is just due to luck. Or does it mean the position that the HoYD would prefer to play the player in? This is especially true when you are making progress in trying to maximize chances of getting good youth intakes by hiring the best head of youth development, asking the board to invest more funds into youth recruitment and improving the clubs reputation amongst other things. 7. It's not my channel, but something which I like to watch. i did some analysis myself in my topic but nothing compared to what you are doing. Highest CA 118. It says those numbers are organised due to players preferred role. Or is that what is best for the player? It will be interesting to see how that translates to the actual intake itself. Sign up for a new account in our community. Be mindful though, if you see a player with high potential, sign them immediately before another club takes them from under your nose. When you get to the Championship or the Premier League, you can then turn your attention to maximizing the potential of your youth system. This will happen from time to time even when they have the best rating of 20 in judging player ability and judging player potential. Highest PA 161. Press J to jump to the feed. It's lazy and it needs to be called out more in my opinion. The truth is that you need to think what you want out of them and when you want it by, and then sort of reverse engineer it backwards so that you give them the development that will get them there. My 1st choice striker in Portugal is a bloke called(32g) Ramos (POR). It takes time, it takes patience and it needs a dollop of luck. The chances are we will lose him, (by about age 26/27 at the latest I think), and I need to have other options because I can't just go out and buy someone to replace him. A Head of Youth Development with Catenaccio as his Tactical Style will often train new players with the Libero role and one with a 5-3-2 as his preferred formation will often produce defensive midfielders and wingbacks. These will increase the prospect of a 'golden generation' or two for your club, but you won't get quality players every. The easiest way to do so is by pressing CTRL+W, for as long as you havent changed your hotkeys. You're correct though. 8. Because my current save is a second attempt at the Alex Ferguson challenge. Each club has a rating between 1-20 for each category. #FM22Challenge #FM22 #FM22_Journeyman #footballmanager2022 #footballmanager" 15. We don't have a HoYD, but this is the bloke in charge of the intake. The levels of Youth Recruitment are: Let's continue with our previous hypothesis that Brazilian clubs can produce 2 S tier players, 3 A tier and 4 B tier. Without further ado, let's get into it. Let's make a list of all the things that are static and remain the same in each of the 10 profiles. Game time. PA values ending in a 0 digit = 15 (18%). 26.24Control Group Average PA. 73.09Minimal Facilities Average PA. 33.01. I "think" it's too simplistic to say that there is a cut-off like that, but without running an experiment it's hard to quantify, and I would expect the results of any experiment in this area to be open to significant amounts of interpretation, (which is not really the idea). The PA result was a little better, coming out on top of both minimum facilities and maximum training groups. In your example above, the highest PA moved between the 160-180 range. Then we have our affiliates, (we have 7), 2 of which are in playable leagues. We've already calculated that based on the laws of probability, we should expect to see something like 32 occurrences of this in each section so how many have we got? The video I looked at concerned the impact of (Pro), (Amb), (Det) and Morale on player growth with is pretty relevant to this thread and I really liked it. 7. Training Facilities allowed players at the club to improve, Youth Facilities allowed the Youth players, (not yet through the intake), to improve, Junior Coaching largely impacted on Newgen CA and Youth Recruitment largely impacted on Newgen PA. 1. We've only recently been given a B Team, (we're in 2050 now and I still haven't won the Liga Bwin), and for a while I was just keen to batter the opposition and field the strongest side I could in the B Team but now I have a different strategy. The likelihood of actually generating these players will change from club to club and that is what we will explain below. Fair play, you're right that I may have remembered that from a previous version and it's all changed since then. This should help to show something like lowering the youth facilities reducing the PA of individual players but if your Youth Recruitment is high, you're still getting the same volume of players coming through, and vice versa, do we care about youth recruitment if we're still getting high individual PA players coming through with regularity. Home of exclusive FM tools \u0026 the Scouting Platform. 2nd Nationality. As a result I have 2x 18 year old DR's 1x 21 year old DR, 1x 22 year old DR and a 23 year old DR. Once I have developed them I will either loan them out or sell them to generate income, but the big thing is I have to develop them 1st so that when and if I do need to go and buy someone, I will know that I have these 5 right backs that I have developed to a level that they can all come in and do a job for us. This was how it had been explained and this is how we understood it to work. So not how good the player actually is, but how good whoever is compiling the reports things he is). We say with 100% certainty because there's always a lot of speculation and opinions on what the best methods and approaches are, but this guide will focus on things that are either confirmed in-game or have been confirmed by the developers. 5 players at 150+ PA. If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. It was very much a short-term thing. "Youth Intake Preview - December 2025 I'm quite excited with this 'Excellent' Youth Intake, who have the potential to be a real golden generation for the club. Highest CA 103. I would love to do even a very basic/limited experiment in this area so I will add it to the list. On the 1st of every month add every newgen from the previous month to your shortlist, this takes seconds. Sports Interactive 2016 In terms of CA, the L20 Training Facilities performed only slightly better than the min facilities test. That's a bit weird. owners. Unfortunately, there is nothing you can do to modify this value, outside of editing with the in-game editor and other cheats. People pretending that they are the big I am simply to get clicks. This preview suggests that we have a "GK who is a "great prospect" and not 1 but 2 strikers who are regarded as "fine prospects". (So think of them as 11, 12, 13, 14 & 15 years olds all playing aged group football). If it doesn't give us an exact picture, it should at least give us an indication. From what I have seen I don't have any issue with his stuff being posted in here. We and our partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. As a second point, but also an addendum, when we refer to top clubs, we dont necessarily mean so in terms of quality or reputation, but in terms of Youth Recruitment. (Hopefully it should make more sense as I start to progress through it). you can check out this one about comparing development. My theory is some of them are poached away Reply DallyTheGreat 1 yr. ago You can learn more about our editorial policies here. 14. Head of Youth Development. What influences the Nationality & Secondary Nationality of players? Total intake is result of two division's intake. One of the hardest things in Football Manager - after not putting your fist through the screen when you concede a 95th minute equaliser against Luton - is learning how to develop youth players in FM22. Football Manager 2023 (Both PC and Console versions) releases today! Preferred foot. If you look at post 2, you will see that there are 10 different Youth Intake previews. Your club gets a fresh pack of Newgens and every year you have the hope that at least one of those virtual kids has the potential to become one of your star players. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc or its affiliates, Here Are The Best Complete Forwards In FM23, Here Are The Best Deep Lying Forwards In FM23, The Best Way to Use Inverted Wing Backs in Football Manager. As well as the quality of the players in each position, the quantity can also be important. Both of these contribute to the potential for wonderkids and overall good youngsters. A weird single intake was observed in June. The Football Manager 2023 winter transfer update includes a number of essential changes to the FM23 database. 3 players at 150+ CA. What Does Golden Generation Mean in Football Manager? Now obviously this is what I "think" (or more accurately, what I've heard) rather than provable fact, but from what I understand, the development priorities are: <18 - training is more important for development, so if you have better facilities it's better to keep them in youth squad for their development (assuming not good enough to play, at least as sub for first team). As the club we're experimenting with in Spain is actually Melilla, (who are based on the African mainland), I would expect to see more Africans and certainly more Moroccans, but whether that's incorporated into the game I don't know. On the day of the youth intake, your newgens. He does say U23 games count so recommends making sure it's a balanced and filled out squad to help them win and obtain good match performances. Optimising Youth Intake I think it would help to see the total PA & CA of the intakes as well as the basic number of players. It's only 14 mins long and he deals with 4 slightly different topics and even came up with a conclusion that surprised him, so rather than ignoring it or just blindly accepting it, (he was using quite a small sample size), he actually created a test to work out if the experiment was correct or if his initial assumption had been correct all along. Trademarks and brands are the property of their respective Fm22 Tips Youth Intake Football Manager 2022 are a great way to get around town without the hassle of driving. Plus medical staff to try and ensure my hot prospects are as protected from injury as possible. Though sorry it evolved from you getting annoyed at someone else's lack of candour online. 2. He's found the back of the net on 8,944 occasions and provided a remarkable 2,926 assists - that works out at a direct goal contribution every two games. It's relative to the players you have at your club already. In the dim and distant past, the roles of facilities were quite specialised. 18. Media Handling style. The 1st thing I'm going to up in the Editor is Training Facilities. Even clubs like Ajax, Barcelona and Manchester United famed for their youth system rarely promote 2 or 3 players each year who can consistently feature in their first team. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Is there any truth to this or is it just an old FM players tale? https://bit.ly/fmscout-youtube FOLLOW FMSCOUTSite https://www.fmscout.comTwitter https://twitter.com/fmscoutFacebook https://www.facebook.com/fmscoutDiscord https://discord.gg/fmscout I should add that unfortunately [Name redacted] aren't alone in chatting absolute rubbish about things they know very little about I should have done this long before now but we all know how real life is. I think you might really get something out of having a little look at my thread and looking at the comparisons between the PPA ratings (the stars), and the actual PA, (the number). There are absolutely players I failed to develop properly, (especially in the early seasons of the save), and even now there are players that I fail with. 9 out of the 10 intakes were classed as golden generations, and what seemed strange to me is that the preview with the highest rating of B was still a golden generation, but Preview (with just 1 A rating), wasn't classed as a golden generation. Click here to read our list of best youth academies in FM22 and you'll be sure to find yourself a bargain. What we do know is that it will be the position, or 1 of the positions in which the player where the player has "Natural" ability. Football Manager 2022 is here, which means it's time to dust off your suit and tie and get ready for another rollercoaster season. If your squad already has the likes of Mbapp and Haaland, do not expect many 4 or 5 star potential youngsters. Mika Biereth an 18 year old forward and Miguel Azeez 19 year old midfielder. I will have a look at that at some point. FM22 Journeyman on Twitter: "We've all had a golden generation, last years youth intake was one too! It covers from 15 to 30 years old. How Youth Recruitment Affects Youth Intake. What happens if you compare 10 different Youth Intakes from the same preview to 10 different intakes from 10 different previews? 39.74Minimal Facilities Average CA. I say that with special reference to the fact that we know that the "Youth Intake Preview" is a relatively new addition as a feature, so if they changed that what else have they changed. Nothing else have changed. Let's say there's a default 1% chance of producing an S tier player for every club. Something has caught my eye when posting the 1st few results and when it happened again, (but even more pronounced this time), I decided that it wasn't just my brain playing tricks on me so I would mention it and look at it. What happens if I edit the Youth Rating, both before the preview and after? Then you get the more uncertain road of a loan. 8. Bringing through the next generation of world-class stars is one of Football Manager's most appealing features - youth development is a journey that takes time to get right. It's free and only takes a few seconds. Enormously!!!! I certainly plan on looking at Nationalities at some point, (but was thinking more along the lines of staff Nationalities & Club Affiliations. Even though you know they are not the same, you might be surprised by quite how different they can be. We have 16 players in the intake (down the left hand side). 39/64 47/57 39/88 35/63 51/62 48/74 37/108 59/74 39/80 46/84 His PA ranges from 57-108 which again doesn't fit into any single range and actually has to be spread over 4 different ranges. Just to confuse things further, normal order is resumed for Youth Recruitment where Adequate again comes before Average. Newgens are completely unique players, rather than replicas of retired players. Intake Distribution by preferred position. If you're lucky enough to be good enough to get a chance in our team then you get exposure to all the factors that would serve as a catalyst for advancing high potential. RIght? Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. You're dreaming about bringing through a 200 PA striker who will make Erling Haaland look like Yaya Sanogo. But I've got two players. Most of us look at CA in terms of the stars, but if you can't develop the player from his low CA starting point to his potential PA then the high PA doesn't really mean anything. The member of staff that is responsible for selecting the players to appear in your youth intake, as well as inform you of it, can be configured in the Staff Responsibilities. Director of Football. There are 8 levels of Youth Recruitment, and to see it, you have to go to Club Info, Facilities and you'll see your level of Youth Recruitment at the bottom. Plus after a little research the only player of Man Utds "class of 92" to go out on loan was Beckham in 1995, where he played all of five games for Preston North End. Guess the question is does each player account for a single number on the graphic. There may have already been experiments to test this, although I'm not sure exactly how you might do so. Is it possible for a player to have more than one preferred role? didn't actually see this thread at the time, i think i have mentioned at times on your career thread my ideas on the youth intake. Best FM22 Wonderkids FM22 Players Under 25 FM22 Transfer Budgets FM22 Youth Facilities Graphic Megapacks Cut Out Facepack V2023.06 - 10 Feb 2023 . It still needs some scrolling and this is the hidden section, (so we weren't missing much). I "think" the only location that is taken into account is the "Region" the club is in, (in this case Western Europe). What happens if I edit the Nation reputation, both before the preview and after? The dates that regens are added into the game are known as Youth Intake days. Absolutely nothing is static. I appreciate 10 saves is a tiny number, but the truth is I just can't be bothered to do 100, (which would give great info I think). Today, Jake. The dream is for a 'golden generation' of youth and, even better than that, a player that "could possibly emerge as one of the best players of his generation." Spoiler alert - you won't always get good players. I found a lot of information before i started in a few youth intake topics . 14. What can change? 15. Yes of course there is a balance to be had here and if you play a player too much too young, then the chances are he will pay a price at the back end of his career. Something that I think a lot of us fall foul of, (especially those of us who play Youth Only saves), is that we start developing a player and we invest maybe 1 or 2 years into him and then someone comes out of the intake 2 years younger than him who has better PA, so we then concentrate on the younger guy and the 1st bloke sort of falls by the wayside. Training performances, (driven my multiple things). -10 170-200-95 160-190-9 150-180-85140-170-8 130-160-75 120-150-7 110-140-65 100-130-6 90-120-55 80-110-5 70-100-45 60-90-4 50-80-35 40-70-3 30-60 We have a CA and a PA score for each player across 10 different intakes.